Showing posts with label human rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label human rights. Show all posts

Monday, April 19, 2021

World Happiness Index 2021; We're Number One?

America's Rank: Incarceration, Happiness and Life Expectancy

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all [people] are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted . . .."
Declaration of Independence, July 4, 1776

"The care of human life and happiness and not their destruction is the only legitimate object of good government."
Thomas Jefferson, to Maryland Republicans, 1809, The Writings of Thomas Jefferson, Memorial Edition, 1903-04

"Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of [themselves and their] family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond [their] control."
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, United Nations, Article 25(1), 1948
A true patriot looks for ways to make America's democracy stronger, and then sets about trying to make it happen. That requires confronting and acknowledging where we're a few cars off the rails. It also requires a little modesty born of a fact-based examination of reality. A patriot knows America is great enough to, borrowing from Jack Nichiolson's line, "handle the truth."

So what about this "We're Number One!! We're Number One!!" business?

We are number one among all nations with some things. In defense spending we're not only number one, we spend approximately what is spent by the next 10 nations combined! [In order: China, India, Russia, Saudi Arabia, France, Germany, United Kingdom, Japan, South Korea and Brazil. See "Comparison: Government Defence Expenditure," countryeconomy.com.]

We're also number one in prison population (2016/2017). We have 2,153,600 prisoners -- roughly 600,000 more than number 2, China (1,561,086). But that's not a fair comparison; the better figure is prisoners per 100,000 population. By that standard we have 6 times more prisoners than China: 662.5 per 100,000 to China's 110.4 per 100,000. [See "Total Prison Population," countryeconomy.com.]


So how are we doing when it comes to the happiness of Americans, and the conditions that contribute to one's happiness, goals that were important to our founders -- and those who wrote the Universal Declaration of Human Rights? [Photo of one-year-old on her birthday, displaying enough happiness to put her well up on anyone's "happiness index."]

America ranks, not "number one!" in happiness, but nineteenth in the list below. How those nations rank in life expectancy is represented in the number following "LE."



1 - Finland - LE 19
2 - Denmark - LE 24
3 - Switzerland - LE 6
4 - Iceland - LE 8
5 - Netherlands - LE 25
6 - Norway - LE 5
7 - Sweden - LE 16
8 - Luxembourg - LE 23
9 - New Zealand - LE 22
10 - Austria - LE 27
11 - Australia - LE 11
12 - Israel - LE 10
13 - Germany - LE 29
14 - Canada - LE 20
15 - Ireland - LE 9
16 - Costa Rica - LE 32
17 - United Kingdom - LE 26
18 - Czech Republic - LE 44
19 - United States - LE 42

It's something to think about; for example, "What do those top 7 nations have that we don't -- and why?" And then? Then try to do something about it.

Sources: World Happiness Index 2021 (click on "Countries" to list countries alphabetically, and "World Happiness Ranking" to list countries by happiness), and World Happiness Report 2021 ("The World Happiness Report is a publication of the Sustainable Development Solutions Network, powered by data from the Gallup World Poll and Lloyd’s Register Foundation, who provided access to the World Risk Poll. The 2021 Report includes data from the ICL-YouGov Behaviour Tracker as part of the COVID Data Hub from the Institute of Global Health Innovation."). The "Life Expectancy at Birth" rankings can be found HERE.

Sunday, March 04, 2018

Bars, Students Should be Thankful

Note: A Letter to the Editor of the Iowa City Press-Citizen, November 3, 2013, was inadvertently not reproduced in FromDC2Iowa at the time and so has been added now, March 5, 2017.

Bars, Students Should Be Thankful
Nicholas Johnson
Iowa City Press-Citizen, November 3, 2013, p. A8

Bars are in the business of profiting from the sale of alcohol. Those under 21 are legally prohibited from buying, possessing, or consuming alcohol. The most logical and easily administered standard would be to keep those under 21 from entering bars, as is done elsewhere.

Instead, Iowa City enables bar owners to profit maximize, and those who cannot legally purchase alcohol to be in their bars 20 hours a day. They are excluded only from 10 p.m. to 2 a.m. It's scarcely "21-only."

Our City Council's approach is exceedingly generous to bar owners and their student customers alike, something for which they should be grateful rather than protesting.

To keep the underage, 20-hours-a-day bar access, you vote "No." To repeal it you vote "Yes." So voters may be confused. They may not even vote. But few are undecided.

So why write more?

Because there are a couple of really bizarre bits of rhetoric the controversy has inspired that need examination.

One is that people who are legally precluded from purchasing what a business is selling are deprived of their "human rights" if they are kept out of such establishments for the four hours each day when they cause the most mischief.

There are all kinds of laws restricting those underage from, among other things, getting married, driving cars, buying guns, performing in porn videos, purchasing cigarettes -- and yes, alcohol. Never, before now, has any been considered a human-rights violation.

The other is that because the drinking age should be 18, rather than 21, therefore it's OK for underage students to violatre the law and drink alcohol. I follow that argument "all but the 'therefore.'"

Until they persuade the Legislature of their position, (1) keeping those under 21 out of bars is logical, (2) permitting them in bars until 10 p.m. is generous, and (3) leaving them there until 2 a.m. is just asking for trouble -- the trouble we got the last time we tried it.

See, "Underage Drinking As Human Right? I Don't Think So," and links.

Nicholas Johnson
Iowa City

# # #

Saturday, January 20, 2018

Religious Rights and Civil Wrongs on Campus

NOTE: This blog post does not constitute "legal advice." It does not even rise to the level of a "legal opinion" derived from legal research. It is merely an informal, uninformed exploration of some questions the dispute suggests to the author. If you are personally involved in, or affected by, litigation related to the issues discussed, you should consult a lawyer. — Nicholas Johnson, Iowa City, Jan. 20, 2018

UPDATE on Federal Court proceeding: Federal District Court Judge Stephanie Rose granted plaintiffs, Business Leaders in Christ, a temporary injunction on January 23, 2018. This will permit the BLC an opportunity today (January 24) to participate in the UI "recruitment fair" and sign up additional members. Note that this is not a final decision in this case. It only applies to the next 90 days. It does, however, require that the judge has rejected any prejudgment that there is no way the plaintiffs could possibly win on the merits (not that they will win). — N.J., Jan. 24, 2018

Additional Contents


Appendix

How the University of Iowa Became 'Congress'"

Newspaper Coverage and Related Matter

A member of a University of Iowa student organization that calls itself Business Leaders in Christ (BLC), asserts that, "put simply, the school is discriminating against our group because it doesn’t like our Christian beliefs." The University insists it’s simply enforcing the legal and regulatory human and civil rights of LGBTQ students. [Jacob Estell, "Why Did UI Single Out Christian Group?" Des Moines Register, December 14, 2017; and Ira Lacher, "Op-ed left out important facts," Des Moines Register, December 22, 2017.]

What that student "put simply" is now a federal district court case. Business Leaders in Christ v. University of Iowa, U.S. District Court, S.D. Iowa, Eastern Div'n, Civil Action No. 17-cv-00080-SMR-SBJ, Memorandum in Support of Application for Preliminary Injunction Oral Argument Requested (Expedited relief before January 24, 2018 requested), December 13, 2017; Declaration of Hannah Thompson; Declaration of Kimberlee W. Colby; kDeclaratiion of Jacob Estell; Declaration of Eric Baxter.

In this age of political divisiveness — "us" vs. "them" — few political movements, if any, can resist using various forms of an often successful litigation strategy. For some, the "them" are the "billionaires and corporations."

In this case, the "them" are what the plaintiffs' financial backers, and those of similar persuasion, have at times asserted are one or more of the following: elitist, liberal, politically correct, ivory-tower, anti-Christian college faculty and students.

So who are the "us," the financial and legal backers of BLC? It’s a group called the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty — perhaps best known for its work on the Hobby Lobby case. Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, 573 U.S. ___ (2014).

Here’s how The American Prospect describes the organization:
By choosing cases that will . . . slow the progression of same-sex marriage, critics contend, the fund has become ideological. The money seems to point in that direction. . . In 2012, the Becket Fund received almost a quarter of a million dollars from DonorsTrust, a shadowy middleman used to funnel money from benefactors like Charles and David Koch to conservative think tanks and advocacy groups. (The Becket Fund declined repeated requests for comment about its work and funding.)
Amelia Thomson-DeVeaux, "The Spirit and the Law; How the Becket Fund became the leading advocate for corporations’ religious rights," The American Prospect, June 18, 2014.

Thus, at the outset we need to recognize that this is not what one might normally think of as a "lawsuit." This is not two corporations suing each other because they can't resolve their differences; a consumer suing one of them; or a suit for damages suffered from personal injury in an automobile accident.

This lawsuit at least raises the possibility that it is but a single case in a nationwide political and ideological effort to make the case that (a) Christianity is under siege, and that (b) higher education is engaged in brainwashing young minds with socialism, liberal ideology, and agnostic to atheist religious views — including acceptance of same-sex marriage.

Indeed, it is even possible that Becket may have been involved in some way with the creation of the BLC, shortly before this conflict arose, in anticipation of a federal court case. I have no way of knowing if that occurred or not. Plaintiffs allege the organization has eight-to-ten members. I've not seen their names, and even if 10 that's 3/100ths of 1% of the student body. Moreover, BLC's filings in the case include a document making reference to a prior controversy at the University of Iowa nearly identical to this one. Declaration of Kimberlee W. Colby.

An effort to "follow the money" in this case is a story all its own. But with some exceptions, who is behind a law suit and why is of little relevance to the legal rights of the parties. Even serial killers are entitled to their constitutional rights. And Becket and BLC members are as well, almost regardless of motives.

Student organizations can increase their membership at the University of Iowa’s "recruitment fairs." The next one is scheduled for January 24-25, 2018. Because the controversy has resulted in the decertification of BLC as a student organization, it will not be able to participate. Therefore, Becket is asking the court for a "preliminary injunction" — by which one assumes it means the reinstatement of plaintiff as a student organization prior to January 24.

The primary requirement for preliminary injunction relief is a demonstration of the probability the plaintiff will ultimately win a permanent injunction.

Becket argues that BLC will ultimately win reinstatement, because plaintiff’s constitutional rights have been violated by the University.

Becket sites the First Amendment; but because it only limits "Congress" ("Congress shall make no law . . .") does it even apply to the University of Iowa? Yes; for the reasons why the University would be included in what the Founders called "Congress," see the Appendix, below.

What might be of relevance in the First Amendment? There are primarily three clauses (plus another three discussed below): The University "shall make no law ["law" includes "regulations"] respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech. . .."

Although the BLC's student spokesperson believes the University "doesn’t like our Christian beliefs," it’s important to distinguish between (a) beliefs that are held by students but not expressed, (b) the expression of students' beliefs in speech or writing, and (c) actions driven by those beliefs.

The University could not even know, and certainly does not restrict, students’ unarticulated beliefs or other thoughts — whether regarding religion or other subjects.

The University neither restricts students’ expression of their beliefs, nor could it legally do so — subject to some exceptions, such as disruption of the University's educational mission, or the provocation of "imminent lawless action."

This case involves BLC's actions — namely, its refusal to permit one of its members, who is openly gay, from running for a leadership position in the organization. It contends that student organizations, and student religious organizations most of all, must be permitted to retain what it believes is their constitutional right to insist that its leaders share the mission of the organization and the beliefs of its members.
Consider this hypothetical. From 1844 to 1978 the Mormon Church withheld from African Americans the opportunity to enter its priesthood — with theological arguments to support its position. Max Perry Mueller, "Is Mormonism Still Racist?" Slate, March 2, 2012. Assume that, prior to 1978, the University of Iowa had the same human and civil rights policies it has today. If the BLC's rationale were to be applied to that set of facts, could a UI Mormon Students Association successfully insist that it had a constitutional right to bar African American Mormon members from its leadership, while still enjoying the benefits of a UI-certified student organization? If not, why not; what is the distinction?
Note that University has not forbidden the existence of BLC in Iowa City, has not indicated a desire to do so, and probably could not do so. That is not at issue in this case.

This case merely involves whether a student organization at the University of Iowa, insisting on its asserted constitutional right to violate the University's written policies regarding students' human and civil rights (made expressly applicable to student organizations), is nonetheless constitutionally entitled to receive the benefits accorded University-certified student organizations. These benefits include such things as access to meeting rooms, participation in recruitment fairs, and financial support. Registration of Student Organizations ("It is the responsibility of each registered student organization to adhere to the mission of this University, its supporting strategic plan, policies, and procedures.")

All of which brings us to the distinctions between a "public forum" and a "limited public forum."

If the University, or other state institution, makes an auditorium or meeting rooms available to all organizations and members of the public, it has created a "public forum." As such, the institution cannot exclude any individual applicant or group from access to the public forum because of their religious beliefs, ideology or the content of their speech.

But that is not a public institution's only option. It can also create a "limited public forum" — that is, an auditorium or meeting rooms that are only available for designated groups or purposes. For example, use could be limited to "official university functions," or "college or department-sponsored events." That is, in effect, what the University of Iowa has done with regard to students' access to facilities, "recruitment fairs," and financial support. This privileged access is limited to student groups that have been certified as compliant with, among other things, the University's policies regarding individuals human and civil rights.

There is the possibility of some ambiguity in the BLC’s approach to students who identify as LGBTQ.

The BLC seems to accept the University’s Human Rights Policy requirement that BLC welcome all otherwise qualified students to membership regardless of the applicants’ sexual orientation. BLC Website, Membership Process ("The organization accepts anyone at any time throughout the year and will not discriminate against anyone on the basis of race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, disability or any other factor. However, because it is geared towards business students, the target audience for this organization would be for students already admitted into the Tippie College of Business, pre-business students, or students considering business as a major/minor.")
The University is guided by the precepts that in no aspect of its programs shall there be differences in the treatment of persons because of race, creed, color, religion, national origin, age, sex, pregnancy, disability, genetic information, status as a U.S. veteran, service in the U.S. military, sexual orientation gender identity, associational preferences, or any other classification that deprives the person of consideration as an individual, and that equal opportunity and access to facilities shall be available to all. (emphasis added)
Operations Manual, Ch. 3, Human Rights, Sec. 3.1; and Policies, I. Student Rights, F. University Policy on Human Rights.

The University's enforcement of these requirements is complaint-driven — thereby avoiding the intrusion, administrative difficulty, and excessive costs of investigations into the detailed operations of every student group on campus. Anyone can complain of violations, and if they do the University will inquire into the facts. My guess is that the issue plaintiffs are asserting (the University's prejudice against "Christian beliefs") has either never, or very seldom, arisen before. Thus, it is not surprising that when plaintiffs did undertake an investigation they were able to find what they allege to be the inconsistent enforcement of the human rights standards they are charged with violating. (Obvious examples would be sports teams, or Greek organizations, that limit membership to a single sex. They also found a Muslim organization with standards similar to those of BLC with regard to beliefs of the organization's leaders.) However understandable, this inconsistency in enforcement may be a problem with the University's defense. It may, at a minimum lead to a reexamination, and restatement, of the application of the University's policies regarding human and civil rights.
"U.S. District Court Judge Stephanie Rose pressed UI attorney George Carroll, specifically, on whether UI has addressed allegations it unequally enforced its human rights policy by deregistering Business Leaders in Christ for barring an openly-gay student. The student organization — which goes by BLinC — has argued other UI groups limit membership and leadership to those who agree with their ideals and religious beliefs, including Imam Mahdi, which reserves leadership posts for Shia Muslims and requires they 'refrain from major sins.' 'Has the University of Iowa taken any steps to ensure that organization has modified its constitution?' Rose asked about the Muslim group. Carroll answered, 'No.'" Vanessa Miller, "Federal judge presses University of Iowa on singling out religious student organization," The Gazette, January 19, 2018, p. A1.
It is true that BLC insists there should be a distinction between a certified student organization’s inability to reject members and what should be its freedom to apply stricter standards with regard to its selection of officers of the organization. (Becket argues an analogy to the "ministerial exception," that “a religious group’s 'selection of its ministers is unfettered.'" Brief, above, pp. 21 et seq.)

But even with regard to officers, there is an additional ambiguity in BLC’s position.

On the one hand, there is the suggestion that the organization’s Christian values are at odds with any male student self-identifying as gay –- which, while not precluding that student’s membership, would preclude their sharing leadership as an officer of the organization. (Depending on one's approach to the member-officer distinction, this would constitute a clear violation of the University's Human Rights Policy.)

On the other hand, there seems to be, as well, the profession of BLC’s Christian value that sexual relations outside of a marriage relationship are sinful. It is suggested that while individual occurrences of such a sin would not be disqualifying for BLC leadership (once appropriately atoned for), an open rejection of that value as a restraint on one’s behavior would be disqualifying –- possibly for membership, but certainly for leadership.

The complainant — an openly gay member who wished to be considered for leadership — was told he could not be an officer. It is possible that the BLC decision was grounded, not in the complainant’s sexual orientation status (his outing himself as gay), but rather on his insistence that he intended to continue to pursue sexual relations outside of marriage.

If so, and BLC applies the same standards to straights and gays alike (because sexual promiscuity is not one of the University’s protected human rights), the BLC’s decision would not seem to be a violation of the University’s prohibition of exclusion based on sexual preference.

As promised, not only is this blog post not legal advice, neither does it offer any answers, predictions of the judge's ruling, or proposals for revisions in the University's policies.

Moreover, there are many other issues involved in this case, and the others around the country involving student Christian organizations. It will continue to be interesting to follow how this case evolves over time.

# # #

APPENDIX

"Establishment," "Free Exercise," and Why the University is "Congress"

The University of Iowa has denied "Business Leaders in Christ" its status as a student organization because of what the University believes to be BLC's alleged anti-gay policies. WWJD (what would Jesus do)? Apparently, Jesus would sue the University in federal court, because that's what BLC is doing. Neither facts nor law are clear.

Constitution. Let’s start with the Constitution.

Mention "the First Amendment" and most folks (including myself) think "freedom of speech."

Of course, 'free speech" and "press" (media) are not only mentioned there, they are among the fundamental pillars of democracy. [See, "Defending Democracy," December 3, 2017.]

But so are other foundations of our democracy: the right "peaceably to assemble" and to "petition the government for a redress of grievances."

Religious Freedom. In fact, the First Amendment begins, not with freedom of speech, but with freedom of religion:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Is the UI "Congress"? How can the First Amendment, with its restraints on the Congress ("Congress shall make no law . . .") even apply to the University of Iowa?

Simple. The Supreme Court is said to have created this "interpretation" of the word "Congress," by adhering to Humpty Dumpty's assertion that, "When I use a word it means just what I choose it to mean" [Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass, chapter 6, "Humpty Dumpty," (1871).]

Being lawyers, the justices’ logical analysis was not, in fact, that simple. Consider the case of Gitlow v. New York, 268 U.S. 652 (1925). Although the facts involve a fascinating bit of American history giving rise to New York’s punishment of Gitlow for his speech, we’ll jump to the Court’s reasoning. True, the words of the First Amendment don’t apply to New York. However, the words of the Fourteenth Amendment do: "nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." This led the Court to reason — or leap, as you may see it — to assert:
freedom of speech and of the press which are protected by the First Amendment from abridgment by Congress are among the fundamental personal rights and "liberties" protected by the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment from impairment by the States. [268 U.S. 652, 666]
There you have it. The Bill of Rights, including the First Amendment, which are not, by their words, applicable to the states, are simply "incorporated" into the "due process" clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which clearly is applicable to the states. ["Incorporation of the Bill of Rights," Wikipedia.org]

And that is how the University of Iowa became "Congress," forbidden by the First Amendment to either "establish" a religion, or prevent a religion’s "free exercise."

# # #

Some Newspaper Coverage and Related Matter

Naomi Hofferber, "UI expels Christian student club over leadership requirement," The Daily Iowan, December 12, 2017

Christian Legal Society v. Martinez, 561 U.S. 661 (2010)

” One Iowa Responds to Becket Fund’s Lawsuit Against the University of Iowa,” December 13, 2017;

Vanessa Miller, "Christian Organization: UI Ban Was Religious Bias; University of Iowa Dropped Student Group Over Its Treatment of Gay Member," The Gazette, December 14, 2017, p. A1;

Andy Davis, "Religious Liberty Case: Ousted Christian Student Group Sues UI," Iowa City Press-Citizen, December 14, 2017, p. A1;

Vanessa Miller, "Christian Organization: UI Ban Was Religious Bias; University of Iowa Dropped Student Group Over Its Treatment of Gay Member," The Gazette, December 14, 2017, p. A1

Andy Davis, "Religious Liberty Case: Ousted Christian Student Group Sues UI," Iowa City Press-Citizen, December 14, 2017, p. A1 Michael Fitzgerald, "Christian Group Banned For Kicking Out Gay Student Sues University of Iowa," Towleroad, December 15, 2017;

Vanessa Miller, "Rejected Christian student group wants to recruit at University of Iowa; Motion for injunction says campus recruiting fairs 'crucial' to its existence," The Gazette, December 20, 2017, p. A1

Jacob Estell, "Why Did UI Single Out Christian Group?" Des Moines Register, December 14, 2017 (also, Iowa City Press-Citizen: Jacob Estell, "Why Did UI Single Out Christian Group?" Iowa City Press-Citizen, December 20, 2017, p. A7)

Zachery Schmidt, "University of Iowa Derecognizes Christian Club Because of 'Sexual Moral Conduct' Rules for Leaders: Suit," The College Fix ("Your Right-Minded News and Commentry"), December 20, 2017

David Pitt, "Iowa lawsuit pits gay rights against religious freedom," Associated Press, January 15, 2018

Leigh Jones, "University of Iowa Forces Christian Group Off Campus," World Magazine, January 17, 2018 (with discussion of cases at UC Hastings Law School (5-4 U.S. Supreme Court, favoring school) and Vanderbilt University)

Vanessa Miller, "Federal judge presses University of Iowa on singling out religious student organization," The Gazette, January 19, 2018, p. A1

Vanessa Miller, "Judge Tells UI to Let Faith Group on Campus For Now; Business Leaders in Christ Was Banned For Bias Against Gay Student," The Gazette, January 24, 2018, p. A1 ("U.S. District Court Judge Stephanie Rose sided with Business Leaders in Christ in granting a temporary injunction, which — for now — reinstates the group’s status as a student organization and allows it to recruit at a fair in the Iowa Memorial Union. 'BLinC’s motion is granted based solely upon the university’s selective enforcement of an otherwise reasonable and viewpoint neutral nondiscrimination policy,' Rose’s order states.")

# # #

Additional labels: religion, civil rights, human rights, LGBTQ, University of Iowa, Iowa City, Business Leaders in Christ, student organizations, Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, Hobby Lobby, Donors Trust, Charles Koch, David Koch, Christianity, Constitution, First Amendment, free exercise of religion, establishment of religion, public forum, limited public forum, Vanessa Miller

# # #

Saturday, July 22, 2017

Acceptable, Available, Affordable Housing

Note: An edited excerpt from this blog post (primarily the "Is there a right to housing?" section) was published by The Gazette on August 1, 2017 ("Health Care, Housing Rights?") and reproduced below.

And see, Addendum: "Why Do So Many Christians Believe Lack of Effort is Cause of Poverty, or Jesus Would Oppose Government Social Programs?"

And, for a little good news on this subject, Lee Hermiston, "Shelter House Gets $2.7 Million for 'Housing First' Project in Iowa City; Construction Could Begin in October," The Gazette, August 4, 2017, p. A1.

Excellent and data-loaded: Editorial, "Locked Out: All Counties in Creative Corridor Lack Affordable Homes," The Gazette, August 6, 2017, p. D1 (not yet available online; link will be added when available; excellent data for 7 Iowa counties: population, persons in poverty, percentage who earn less than 30% of median income, number of affordable units for that population, percentages spending more than 30% of income on housing, increase since 2007 in rent for two-bedroom unit compared with percentage increase in median household income, number in 2016 who were homeless and sought emergency services.)

Contents

Is there a right to housing?
Whom are we talking about?
What are their needs; what are the solutions?
Housing in context
What's "affordable"?
Capitalism
Data
Conclusion
____________________

Housing policy is, as President Trump once said of healthcare policy, "an unbelievably complex subject. Nobody knew that [it] could be so complicated." [Michael A. Memoli, "Trump: 'Nobody Knew that Healthcare Could be so Complicated,'" Los Angeles Times, February 27, 2017.]
[For details on polling results and trends regarding the number of Americans who support universal single-payer health care, see Kristen Bialik, "More Americans Say Government Should Ensure Health Care Coverage," Pew Research Center, January 13, 2017 (e.g.: "Currently, 60% of Americans say the government should be responsible for ensuring health care coverage for all Americans, compared with 38% who say this should not be the government’s responsibility.").]
Is there a "right" to housing?

At the outset of discussions of any social program is the threshold issue of "rights": to what extent do we have (legally) or feel (morally) an obligation to care for those beyond our own family, community or "tribes" (variously defined)? To what extent do others have a "right" to expect such care from us?

Obviously, if a majority of us believe, and act as if, others have no "rights," and we have no "obligations," that's pretty much a conversation stopper. So let's first try to figure out what we believe about "rights" in general, by considering some comments from others before returning to the matter of "rights" to housing.
"Right. That which is consonant with equity or the light of nature; that which is morally just or due."
-- Oxford English Dictionary (Compact Ed., vol. II, 1971), p. 669, Right, 3.

"Health care is not a right. Housing is not a right. A job is not a right. College is not a right."
-- Joe Walsh, May 4, 2017 (syndicated radio host; former member of Congress)

"Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself." . . .
"Verily, I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me."
-- Jesus, Matthew 22:39, 25:40 (KJ)

"[W]e can see the TRUTH of the true religion of God woven like a GOLDEN THREAD throughout all faiths whose origin is from Him in the form of the GOLDEN RULE."
-- Bahai, Universal House of Justice (with quotes and citations from 16 major religions; emphasis supplied)

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."
-- Declaration of Independence, July 4, 1776

"Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for . . . health and well-being . . ., including food, clothing, housing and medical care . . .."
-- United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 25, December 10, 1948
There remain differences among us as to whether our obligations to others should be fulfilled through governmental programs or non-governmental organizations' efforts. But as we see, virtually all the world's great religions, and nations (UN), are agreed that we do have at least some obligations to fellow members of our species. (Indeed, some would extend this to other animal (and even plant) species as well. Why? For answers see, Frans De Waal, Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are?" (W.W. Norton, 2016), and Peter Wohlleben, The Hidden Life of Trees (Greystone Books, 2016).)

And yet, among Americans, Joe Walsh (above, "Housing is not a right") speaks for the majority.

This is somewhere between ironic and inexplicable, given that over 50% of Americans say "religion is very important in their lives" (the highest of any wealthy nation). How can we square "I've got mine, Jack," shouts of "Get a job," and denying healthcare to tens of millions of Americans, with the Golden Rule and caring for "the least of these"? How can we explain that "57% of Americans disagreed with the statement 'Success in life is pretty much determined by forces outside our control,' a higher percentage than in any of the European nations polled. . . . [Or that] 73% said hard work is very important for getting ahead in life compared to a European median of 35%. . . . [And that] nearly six-in-ten in the U.S. (58%) believe allowing everyone to pursue their life’s goals without interference from the state is [most] important [, whereas] majorities in all European nations polled in 2011 said guaranteeing that nobody is in need is more important." [Richard Wike, "5 ways Americans and Europeans are Different," Pew Research Center, April 19, 2016.]

In a nation in which a majority holds such beliefs, a nation willing to trust its democracy to a political process fueled (and therefore largely controlled) by the largest campaign donors, it can't be shocking that many elected officials share some donors' belief that "my right to a tax cut trumps (so to speak) your right to come in out of the cold."

Thankfully, there are also thousands of knowledgeable, caring individuals in Iowa and throughout our nation who are trying to do something about insuring every American has decent housing. This blog post is dedicated to them, and addresses the challenges they face.

Whom are we talking about?

Many of us are relatively well housed. Of America's 135 million dwelling units, about 60% (in Iowa and the nation) are single family, detached houses. Others live in condo units or rented apartments. When it comes to housing, these are among the most fortunate, notwithstanding their occasional difficulty paying mortgages, rent, taxes, and utility bills. Thus, with rare exception, housing is not much of an issue for those in the top 20% (annual income $111,000 or more).
["Stats for Stories: American Housing Month," Housing, U.S. Census Bureau, June 2017 ("The 2015 American Community Survey counts almost 135 million housing units in the U.S.: 61.4% are detached single-family homes and 6.3% are mobile homes.") "Most Americans Make It To The Top 20 Percent (At Least For A While)," Planet Money, National Public Radio, May 5, 2014.]
It's a little different story for the homeless -- those roughly 500,000 Americans with no place to call home on any given day. Some have shelter, others are on the streets, or otherwise unsheltered. Some are individuals, including children on their own; some are part of homeless families. They may be chronically homeless or only temporarily so. [Photo credit: unknown.]

Of course, some of those "sheltered" may be couch surfing, or otherwise living in overcrowded conditions shared with other families or friends.

Others may be in a shelter considered unhealthy or otherwise dangerous substandard housing. ("About six million homes in the United States are substandard by American Housing Survey (AHS) standards, a statistic that has seen little change over the last two decades." Dwellings considered substandard have "interior and exterior leaks, signs of pests, and other factors collected by local public health and code enforcement agencies." ["Substandard Housing," National Center for Healthy Housing.
And see, "What Is Substandard Housing?", HomeGuides.sfgate.com ("Substandard housing . . . , often in severe disrepair, [is] housing that poses a risk to the health, safety or physical well-being of its occupants . . . associated with increased risk of disease, crime, social isolation and decreased mental health. . . . Some cases of substandard housing are not so visible. Outdated or dangerous electrical systems, rusting or loose pipes and gas leaks . . . might go unnoticed until an accident happens.")]
Housing can be unsafe for other reasons, such as spousal abuse, or neighborhoods with relatively high levels of violent crime.

The remnants of Americans' prejudice can make it more difficult for some to find housing -- those of a given race, religion, country of origin, new immigrants, or former convicts who've served their time and are trying to reenter society -- regardless of their ability to pay.

But some of those most at risk for becoming homeless are living in "poverty" (defined as an individual with $12,060 annual income or less; $24,600 for a family of four). [Kimberly Amadeo, "Federal Poverty Level: Definition, Guidelines, Chart,"The Balance, February 2, 2017.] Note that "poverty" can result not only from steady employment at a low wage, but also from unsteady, seasonal, or otherwise occasional income (regardless of hourly rate) that doesn't reach an annual total in excess of poverty levels.

The unemployed are an at risk group for housing. "The share of prime-age [American] men (ages 25-54) who are neither working nor looking for work has doubled since the 1970s. . . . [One] in six prime-age men in America are either unemployed or out of the workforce altogether -- about 10 million men" -- one of the highest rates in the world. [Derek Thompson, "The Missing Men," The Atlantic, June 27, 2017.]

Another category are those paying over 50 percent of their income for housing. "When more than 50 percent of a poor household’s income goes to paying rent, that household is experiencing what is known as severe housing cost burden. [These are] households . . . more likely to have an unexpected event -- such as loss of employment or unexpected medical costs -- result in . . . homelessness." [The State of Homelessness in America (2016), pp. 48-49, endhomelessness.org.]
[For one of the best collections of data regarding the financial challenges confronting nearly all Americans regardless of income and net worth, presented in 24 pages of graphics and very readable text, see "On Track or Left Behind? Findings from the 2017 Prosperity Now Scorecard, July 2017 Prosperity Now.org, released July 25, 2017.]
What are their needs; what are the solutions?

Although "categories" are listed above, most of those with housing needs have stories that are somewhat unique -- as are the solutions, to the extent possible.

An abused spouse or children may not be lacking shelter; their problem is not a leaky roof, it's the violence to which they're subjected. They need an alternative shelter, or safe house -- along with some legal assistance -- until they can relocate (or the abuser is imprisoned). There may be other reasons why temporary, rather than permanent, housing is the solution.

For those with a "severe housing cost burden," or without the resources even if they used all their earnings for rent, there may be public housing, "affordable housing" required of landlords, or subsidies such as "Section 8." [Housing Act of 1937, as amended, 42 U.S.C. §1437f.]

Housing in context

As with medical specialists who are less aware of a patient's related conditions, so it is with housing. By contrast, some doctors actually make "house calls" -- not to see the patient, but to see the house, and how it might be contributing to the patient's condition.

For example, in addition to the occasional relationship between housing and healthcare, there is often a relationship between housing, educational level and unemployment.

There can be a relationship between housing, poverty and public transportation (or access to a reliable vehicle). If businesses would build housing close enough to their stores or factories that their employees could walk or bike to work -- with rent they could afford on the hourly wages they were paid -- it would solve both the housing challenge and eliminate employees' costs of commuting from the distances necessary to find affordable housing (as well as improving workers' health and the environment). Public buses or trains that run every 10 or 15 minutes (rather than half-hour or hour), and don't require two or three changes from home to work, would help.

Child care, on the job site or nearby, could sometimes make the difference.

Of course, social workers and others are aware of these interrelated needs and solutions -- as they are aware of not having the necessary resources to do what they know needs to be done. Just as there are IEP's (individual education plans) for K-12 students with disabilities, it would help when addressing individuals' "housing in context" challenges to create a plan for every individual who comes into the system that addresses housing, healthcare, nutrition, transportation, training, childcare and whatever other needs and services are relevant.

What's "affordable"?

There is much reference in discussions of housing to so-called "affordable housing," defined as housing that one can obtain for 30% or less of one's income.
"Families who pay more than 30 percent of their income for housing are considered cost burdened and may have difficulty affording necessities such as food, clothing, transportation and medical care. An estimated 12 million renter and homeowner households now pay more than 50 percent of their annual incomes for housing. A family with one full-time worker earning the minimum wage cannot afford the local fair-market rent for a two-bedroom apartment anywhere in the United States." ["Affordable Housing," Department of Housing and Urban Development.]
"Affordability" is not a very precise concept at best, and is certainly subject to, among other things, almost unlimited potential multiple variables.

Income. Thirty percent of what? What do we count? What do we deduct? Is it what's left after taxes? Which taxes (i.e., federal and state income tax; FICA; sales tax)? What about essential fixed expenses?

Fixed expenses. The minimal, essential expenses for a family of four (or more) will be both different, and far exceed, those for a young, childless single person. Childcare expenses can be significant if there's no grandmother to volunteer. A family paying for grandparents' nursing home costs, or services for a person with a disability, or a mortgage, will have far less for food and other expenses than someone who does not.

Absolute dollars. No one can eat a percentage. Someone in the top 20%, earning $200,000 a year, has $140,000 left over after paying 30% ($60,000; $5,000 a month) for housing. Someone earning the minimum wage ($7.25 an hour) and lucky enough to work 40 hours a week for 50 weeks a year ($14,500 a year) has $10,150 ($846 a month) left over after paying 30% ($4,350, or $362.50 a month -- if such apartments even exist) for housing.

Capitalism

Like a bull in a china shop, or a pig in the parlor, there's nothing inherently wrong with capitalism -- so long as it's kept in its proper place. To protect competitors, employees and consumers some government regulation is often necessary, but "free private enterprise" and "marketplace competition" can produce greater incentives for innovation, productivity and efficiency by business, along with greater choice and lower prices for consumers.

But just as there are some sectors of the economy in which government ownership and operation may not be the optimum approach, there are also other sectors of the economy that seem inappropriate for capitalism.

There are some who seemingly want to privatize everything. But there appears to be at least a significant minority, if not majority, of Americans who recognize the advantages of public ownership and operation of K-12 schools; libraries; national, state, and local parks; and the Interstate Highway system.

Profit-maximizing businesses can have conflicts of interest when providing public goods. Experiments with private ownership of prisons, for example, show that there is an inherent conflict of interest between public policy goals of shorter sentences and alternatives to incarceration and the prison owners' goals of profit maximization: the more people convicted and incarcerated, and the longer their sentences, the greater their profits.

There are doctors and dentists who volunteer in free clinics and elsewhere to provide healthcare to those who otherwise would have to do without. But for the most part healthcare is a private, profit-maximizing industry. As those urging a form of universal, single-payer healthcare say -- a form of healthcare available to citizens in most industrialized countries -- there is a big difference between "health insurance" and "health care." The statistics on such measures as years of life expectancy, or rates of infant mortality, suggest that we are paying more while getting less and serving fewer than those countries. We joke about medical students who want their specialty to be "diseases of the rich," but the fact is that in a capitalist healthcare system everyone from medical professionals, to Big Pharma, to hospitals, to insurance company shareholders and executives would like to be paid more.

Admittedly, there is no more agreement regarding public housing than there is about healthcare. The UN may say, as quoted above, that "Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for . . . health and well-being" (including housing and healthcare), but there are still individuals who believe that even those without shoes should simply "pull themselves up by their bootstraps." [United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 25, December 10, 1948.]

Home builders and realtors will, when necessary, build, remodel, sell, or rent homes and condos to those scarcely able to pay. But when their income is calculated as a percentage of the price of their sold homes, or the square footage of those they've built, large, expensive homes for the wealthy are clearly to be preferred over those for the poor. Segregation in our communities is largely perpetuated by housing policies, which are often driven in part by what the upper 20 percent believe to be "the best schools."

A builder of a city center high rise full of condos, who can sell them for a half-million to a million dollars or more, has zero economic incentive to include units that college students, or minimum wage workers, could afford. Of course, a city government that is gifting the builder a portion of construction costs (say, a TIF that reduces the owner's property taxes) has a lot of leverage -- if it will use it -- to insist on some cheaper units. But that's little more than a tiny one-off contribution to the community's housing needs for the poor and working poor.

Which brings us to "data."

Data

Schools don't just open their doors, let children wander in, and go to whatever room they please. Enrollment is limited by the numbers of classrooms, teachers, and desks. And there are precise records of each child, with information about parents or guardians, address, and perhaps special needs.

Successful businesses startups have business plans. The owners have at least some sense of traffic flow as well as revenue flow, the potential population from which they will draw, the competitors who will be offering the same or similar services.

It's not that those giving their lives to providing housing for the poor aren't aware of the value of comparable information about housing, or that they aren't making efforts to try to create it -- sometimes creative, impressive efforts. It's that they are simply not provided the resources they need to gather all the necessary data. They know, better than I, what they need. But here's how it looks from here.

Take Johnson County, Iowa, as an example. It's helpful to have another Habitat for Humanity house here, a shelter house there, a TIF requiring some below-market units in a condo project. But if we really want to get everyone housed, it's not enough to just "do something." We need some basic data about "supply" -- an inventory of what housing we have (whether occupied or not), such as, how many one-, two-, and three-bedroom apartments there are, with their locations and rent.

The Census Bureau does a pretty good job of counting and reporting housing units. But apparently the landlords and developers are sometimes reluctant to reveal their rental rates and the number of vacancies.

Equally important, is information about "demand" -- especially regarding persons who can't afford any housing available in the county, and those who are suffering from "severe housing cost burden" (rent exceeding half of their income).

It is the demand side that is the most problematical. Ideally there would be enough social workers that every individual in the county in need of one or another form of assistance would be identified, regularly visited, and assisted in finding, or improving, their housing. Unfortunately, in today's political climate that's not likely to happen anytime soon.

However, gathering one county's housing supply and demand is not a "big data" project -- like the recent White House effort to create a database record of every person registered to vote in America, along with their personal data.

There are only 62,000 housing units in Johnson County, and 59 percent of them are owner-occupied -- presumably most of them by owners who are not in need of housing assistance. The remaining 40 percent would be a number that could fit in a single Excel spreadsheet on anyone's laptop computer.

Conclusion

Meanwhile, four things might help. (1) Think about a county's housing challenges as a whole, rather than one dwelling unit, and occupant, at a time. (2) Prioritize the need to gather as much detailed data as possible about the county's housing supply and demand. (3) Recognize that housing is but one of many interconnected challenges for those in need that can most effectively, and efficiently, be met by recognizing how they are connected. (4) Manage the undertaking with measurable goals, timelines, and public accountability in the form of management information reporting systems.

# # #

Here is The Gazette's edited excerpt from this blog post (primarily the "Is there a right to housing?" section):

"Health Care, Housing Rights?"
Nicholas Johnson
The Gazette, Insight Guest Opinion, August 1, 2017, p. A5

There’s been discussion recently about housing (locally) and healthcare policy (nationally). Unlike government-funded programs used by all, these are programs for those most in need.

Developing public policy for social programs seems to be, as President Trump famously said, “an unbelievably complex subject. Nobody knew that [it] could be so complicated.”

That’s not precisely accurate. We are blessed with thousands of knowledgeable, caring individuals who do know how complicated it is.

Do you and I have (legally) or feel (morally) obligations to care for those beyond our family or community? To what extent do others have a "right" to expect such care?

Former Congressman Joe Walsh unambiguously put in his answer: "Health care is not a right. Housing is not a right. A job is not a right. College is not a right."

If healthcare is a product and housing is a privilege; if a majority believe, and act as if, the needy have no "rights," and we have no "obligations," that pretty much ends the discussion.

Where to find insight?

Religion? Jesus said, "Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself" and "Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me." The Bahai Universal House of Justice cites 16 major religions espousing the Golden Rule.

Founding documents? "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."

Virtually all the world's great religions, and nations, agree we have some obligations to fellow members of our species. And yet, Walsh speaks for many Americans.

That's somewhere between ironic and inexplicable, given more U.S. citizens say "religion is very important in their lives" than people elsewhere. How can we square denying healthcare with caring for "the least of these"?

Could it be our “representatives” have adopted their major donors’ belief that "my right to even bigger tax cuts trumps (so to speak) your right to come in out of the cold"?
_______________
Nicholas Johnson is a former FCC commissioner and law professor who maintains the blog, FromDC2Iowa.blogspot.com. Contact: mailbox@nicholasjohnson.org

_______________

Addendum: "Why Do So Many Christians Believe Lack of Effort is Cause of Poverty, or Jesus Would Oppose Government Social Programs?"

Since the publication of this column in the Gazette two categories of responses to my genuine puzzlement (how can our country be both the world's most religious, and so many believe that social programs are "not a right") have come to my attention. One is the disparity between the religious and non-religious regarding the cause of poverty (circumstances vs. lack of effort): Julie Zauzmer, "Christians Are more Than Twice as Likely to Blame a Person's Poverty on Lack of Effort," Washington Post, August 4, 2017 ("53 percent of white evangelical Protestants blamed lack of effort while 41 percent blamed circumstances, . . .. In contrast, . . . Americans who are atheist, agnostic or have no particular affiliation [31 percent blamed lack of effort while 65 percent] said difficult circumstances are more to blame when a person is poor . . ..")

The other came in the form of emails insisting I had misinterpreted Jesus' teachings. Advocating from a WWJD ("what would Jesus do") position, they seemed to be arguing that, (1) were Jesus around to state his case today, he would oppose, or at a minimum not encourage, government programs to help the poor. (2) All Jesus ever said was that individuals should care for "the least of these" -- something that many individuals and churches are doing.

I view this difference of interpretation as analogous to the "original intent" arguments around the "meaning" of the U.S. Constitution. The Constitution refers to an "army" and "navy" but makes no mention of an "air force." Yet no one I know of argues that the Air Force is unconstitutional. To the best of my memory the New Testament has little to say about governmental social programs for the needy -- the existence of such programs during Jesus' years, or even their proposal and rejection. If this was something beyond anyone's imagining at the time (even Jesus' imagining), one can't really fault him for a failure to advocate it.

Were Jesus around today he would probably be denied immigration status, and thus the issue would never arise. But if he was permitted to enter the U.S., it's not unreasonable to suspect -- given what he is credited with saying about caring for others, and the problems flowing from great wealth -- that he would adapt his role of activist to our culture, likely be a Bernie supporter, only be televised on Democracy Now!, and probably advocate for more (rather than less) taxpayer-funded programs for the poor.

# # #

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Underage Drinking As Human Right? I Don't Think So

October 16, 2013, 3:25 p.m.

Why Bar Owners, Students, Should Embrace Iowa City's 21 Law

This morning's Daily Iowan carries an opinion piece arguing that those whom the law forbids to consume alcohol at any time (those under 21) have been denied their human rights by the Iowa City Ordinance forbidding them to be in places of business, the sole purpose of which is to profit from the sale of alcohol, between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 2:00 a.m. Blake Whitten, "21-Ordinance Violates Human Rights," The Daily Iowan, Oct. 16, 2013, p. A4. It is reproduced in full at the bottom of this blog essay.

Those urging repeal of the so-called "21" ordinance come at their efforts at arguments for doing so from a variety of directions. I have already addressed the argument that goes, "because the drinking age should be 18 rather than 21, therefore, those under the age of 21 should be permitted to be in bars between 10:00 p.m. and 2:00 a.m." (even though, I would add, for them to drink during those hours is a clear violation of law). "Deeth's Drinking Age: A Reply; 21 -- 'Not Just a Good Idea, It's the Law,'" October 6, 2013. [Photo credit: lionsdenu.com.]

The following was added by me as a comment to the online version of this morning's Daily Iowan column that attempted to argue why the 21 ordinance is a violation of students' "human rights." It was subsequently published by the Daily Iowan as "Letters to the Editor/Online Comments."

Re: 21-Ordinance is Human-Rights Violation
Nicholas Johnson
The Daily Iowan
October 17, 2013, p. A4
There are all kinds of age-based laws and regulations restricting those underage from, among other things, getting married, driving cars, buying guns, performing in porn videos, purchasing cigarettes -- and yes, alcohol. None is considered a human rights violation. See, "Deeth's Drinking Age: A Reply," http://fromdc2iowa.blogspot.com/2013/10/deeths-drinking-age-reply.html

Bars are in the business of profiting from the sale of alcohol. Those under 21 are legally prohibited from buying, possessing or consuming alcohol. The logical, and most easily administered, standard would be to prohibit anyone under 21 from ever entering a bar -- as is the standard in many places.

Instead, Iowa City lives with a compromise that enables bar owners to profit maximize, and those who cannot legally purchase what they have to sell to be in bars for 20 out of every 24 hours each day. Those under 21 are only kept out of bars from 10 p.m. to 2 a.m. It's scarcely "21-only"!

It seems to me the City Council's approach is exceedingly generous to bar owners and their illegally binge drinking students alike, not something either should be protesting.

And since the author raised the "no one over 50 in bars after 10" example, nor is it a denial of my human rights as an old geezer that I have to get my driver's license renewed more often than my middle-aged children do. Someday it may be forcefully taken from me. The state has a right to determine if my driving puts at risk my own safety and that of others.

As John Neff has noted in a comment on the blog essay linked above, "The age dependence of hazardous use of alcohol decreases much faster than a Constant/Age with most of the problems in the 15 to 25 age range. The peak age is about 19, so 21 is a reasonable compromise for the minimum legal age to drink." In short, that's why the legal drinking age is 21. It, like limitations on my driving, is designed to minimize the risk of harm underage drinkers pose to themselves and others.

Meanwhile, 21 remains the legal drinking age. John Deeth has endeavored (earlier on these pages and elsewhere) to make the case for lowering the drinking age to 18. But until he persuades the Congress and Iowa Legislature of his position, (1) keeping those under 21 out of bars is logical, (2) permitting them in bars until 10 p.m. is generous, and (3) leaving them there until 2 a.m. is just asking for trouble -- the trouble we got the last time we tried.

Here is the Daily Iowan opinion piece to which the above is a response:


21-Ordinance Violates Human Rights
Blake Whitten
The Daily Iowan, October 16, 2013, p. A4.

Imagine that we’re debating a law that reads:

“No person, individual, association, corporation, partnership, or club holding a liquor-control license, wine, or beer permit, which authorizes on-the-premises consumption, nor his or her agents or employees shall allow a person who is 50 years or older to enter or remain in the licensed or permitted establishment between the hours of 10 p.m. and closing.”

Of course, restricting the legal right of older citizens to freely associate is ludicrous, outrageous, and completely unacceptable. As fair-minded Iowans, we wouldn’t stand for such a law, however benevolent the reasons advanced by the law’s proponents and regardless of how many community leaders endorsed it. [Photo credit: San-Antonio-Daily.com.]

Replace the words “is 50 years or older” with “who has not yet attained the legal age,” and you have the 21 bar-entry ordinance.

But is discriminating against a younger demographic of Iowa City citizens really the moral equivalent of discriminating against older citizens? Apparently so, according to Iowa City’s own human-rights ordinance enshrined in the city code:

“It shall be unlawful for any person to deny any other person the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages of any place of public accommodation because of age, color, creed, disability, gender identity, marital status, national origin, race, religion, sex or sexual orientation.”

Apparently staff brought this conflict to the attention of the city recently. In true Orwellian fashion, the council has decided to redefine human rights to specifically exclude the 21-ordinance as a human-rights violation. Poof. Age no longer matters.

City councilors chose a path of political expedience and hypocrisy. But what about the rest of us, those who don’t have political careers to protect or the need to publicly save face? Do we fold human rights neatly into a box that we call the law, or do the inalienable nature of such rights impel us to reconsider the law itself?

I wish that Sally Mason understood the irony that each time she extols the “nanny state” by promoting the 21-ordinance in a speech to the student council or in a press interview, she actually works against instructors who demand personal responsibility, hard work, and academic excellence in the classroom. Students rightly perceive the hypocrisy of the mixed message between rights and responsibilities: “Study hard, but be home in bed by 10 o’clock.”

One issue rarely mentioned is the example we’re setting for our ever-growing contingent of international students, many of whom hail from countries whose governments are considered less than democratic. These students are watching: Is America still the land of the free and the home of the brave? Are vulnerable minorities (in this case, young adults) treated with dignity and respect?

I call on students to vote YES on Public Measure G to affirm that you matter. (It’s especially easy for in-state and out-of-state students to register and vote early at campus locations before Oct. 25.)

Vote YES for your fellow students’ dignity and self-respect. Vote YES to show your international colleagues (international students) that the American dreams of freedom and equality are alive and well, right here in Iowa City.

Much has been debated about safety. The consensus seems to be that downtown is quieter but that house parties are better attended since 2010. But if the goal is a quiet downtown at the expense of freedom, then let’s be fair about it by passing a curfew that forbids everyone from being downtown after 10 p.m. Short of that, and in the great Iowan tradition of grace and fair play, let’s remove the human-rights violation known as the 21-ordinance. Vote yes on Public Measure G.

Blake Whitten is a lecturer in the Department of Economics and the Department of Statistics.