Showing posts with label health insurance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health insurance. Show all posts

Friday, July 28, 2017

GOP Healthcare: Just 'Tell 'em I lied'

An aide to Louisiana Governor "Uncle" Earl Long (1939-40; 1948-52; 1956-60), having faced a group of constituents demanding to meet with the Governor, and angry over his failure to deliver them a promised road, asked Long what the aide should tell the crowd. Governor Long replied,

"Tell 'em I lied."

-- Louisiana Governor Earl Long [full story in Endnote, below]
Why do the Republican members of the House and Senate seemingly feel compelled, like those who self-flagellate their backs with knives and chains, to march on to ever greater self-inflicted wounds, in order to make good on their promise to "repeal Obamacare"? [Photo credit: Gov. Earl K. Long speaking to the Legislature in June 1956; New Orleans Times-Picayune archive.]

Surely they are aware that the titular head of their party -- the President of the United States, Donald Trump -- with all of his lies and broken promises to supporters, has nonetheless enjoyed a successful political career. After all, as he's said of the media, "I'm president and they're not." [Michael D. Shear, "'I'm President and They're Not': Trump Attacks Media at Faith Rally," New York Times, July 2, 2017, p. A18.] As the Times has reported, "There is simply no precedent for an American president to spend so much time telling untruths."
"[H]ere are the numbers for the president’s first 100 days.
492: The number of false or misleading claims made by the president. That’s an average of 4.9 claims a day.
10: Number of days without a single false claim. (On six of those days, the president golfed at a Trump property.)
5: Number of days with 20 or more false claims. (Feb. 16, Feb. 28, March 20, April 21 and April 29, his 100th day in office.)" Glenn Kessler and Michelle Ye Hee Lee, "President Trump’s First 100 days: The Fact Check Tally," Washington Post, May 1, 2017.

And see, David Leonhardt and Stuart A. Thompson, "Trump's Lies," New York Times, Updated July 21, 2017 (with chronological itemized list; "There is simply no precedent for an American president to spend so much time telling untruths. Every president has shaded the truth or told occasional whoppers. No other president — of either party — has behaved as Trump is behaving. He is trying to create an atmosphere in which reality is irrelevant.")
As much as we may admire the congressional Republicans' ethical desire to keep commitments to constituents, why can't they, with regard to this healthcare business, follow their President's example, and that of Governor Earl Long, and simply say, "We lied"?

In fact, they even have a much more acceptable explanation than "we lied." I would suggest they consider something like this:
When Obamacare became law we did not like it. You did not like it. We did not like the process the Democrats used to get it enacted. During the years since, our efforts to repeal it have been frustrated by President Obama's threat to veto any repeal. As you've probably noticed, we've had our difficulties repealing it this year as well.

This is, in large part, a function of the passage of time.

There are things that even the Democrat Obamacare enthusiasts agree are wrong with the law. Whatever else happens, those defects must be fixed.

But after seven years of Americans living with Obamacare, getting access to insurance and healthcare, many of you have come to depend upon it. Few if any of our proposals to repeal it have had the support of more than 15 percent of the American people -- including Republicans. Changes that would continue, or increase, the tens of millions of Americans with no realistic access to Medicaid, Medicare or other adequate health insurance and healthcare, are neither good medicine nor politics.

We have not abandoned our quest, your quest, to improve on Obamacare. What we have come to recognize is that an outright repeal, with or without a replacement, is not politically possible. What is possible is to do better than the Democrats did in fashioning Obamacare while essentially locking us out. What we can do is to start over with the traditional legislative process of staff research, committee hearings with the nation's experts, and full floor debate regarding amendments -- a process that will enable Democrats and Republicans to work together. What we can do is create a process in which facts replace ideological arguments, a process in which every member of the House and Senate has some skin in the game, a process from which can come the best healthcare for all Americans that our representative democracy is capable of creating for the American people.
There's something to the old saying that when you find yourself at the bottom of a deep hole, the first step to getting out is to stop digging. The Republicans continued digging. It hasn't worked. Perhaps it's time to call on Winston Churchill. As Churchill once observed of our democracy, "The Americans will always do the right thing -- after they've exhausted all the alternatives." Now that Congress has pretty well exhausted all the alternatives, perhaps the next step is to do the right thing.

# # #

Endnote
The full story is told by Michael Kurtz and Morgan Peoples:
"During one of his campaigns for governor, Earl Long made a stump appearance before a crowd of farmers in rural St. Tammany Parish. In typical fashion, he promised that if elected, he would have a local road, heavily traveled and full of potholes, widened and paved. Long won the election abnd carried the rural district, but when the legislature convened, he failed to include the promised road work in his agenda of bills. Astonished and furious at this display of gubernatorial duplicity, a large contingent of irate citizens journeyed to Baton Rouge to see Governor Long. Earl would not see them, and they subjected his administrative aide to a barrage of threats and insults. Refusing to leave, they stood their ground and demanded that Long see them. Equally adamant, Earl turned down the impassioned pleas by his aid. The fist-shaking mob gave the aid one last chance, and out of sheer exasperation, he said to Long, "After all, governor, you did promise to have their road paved. What should I tell those people?" With a shrug, Earl replied, "Tell 'em I lied!"
Michael L. Kurtz, Morgan D. Peoples, Earl K. Long: The Saga of Uncle Earl and Louisiana Politics, (LSU Press, 1990), Preface

I will leave to others the search for other possible indicia of similarities between President Trump and the Governors Long, such as, "[Huey] Long became a dictator, disdaining the ordinary processes of constitutional government and flouting the principles of separation of powers. . . . [H]is successors engaged in outrageous acts of personal enrichment, stealing an estimated $100 million from the state [roughly $2 billion today]. . . . [Earl Long] openly practic[ed] spoils politics. He wrecked the state civil service system, fired civil servants for 'political halitosis,' and openly accepted 'campaign contributions' from gamblers and mobsters." Id., p. 9.

# # #

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Healthcare: It's Broken, We're Broke -- and # 37

September 23, 2009, 7:55 a.m.

Healthcare Executive: "System's Broken"
"We're Number 37!" Set to Song

(brought to you by FromDC2Iowa.blogspot.com*)

It's so sad. So disgusting. Not just our profiteering sickness industry, but the "business . . . as usual" performance of those in Washington whom we elect to bring our people up to the level of the civilized nations of this world -- and big business pays to keep them from doing it.

The nations that provide all their people health care -- at a price considerably less than what we're paying to provide care to a select few -- do so with a creative array of variations on "universal, single payer" systems. The longer the debate goes on in this country the more convinced I become that's the only solution for us as well.

And what is this from President Obama: "I will not sign a plan that adds one dime to our deficits -- either now or in the future"? This from Washington, where our two most recent administrations have contributed trillions of dollars to both deficits and debt by handing over our taxpayers' money to corporations, so that they can pay their executives multi-million-dollar bonuses (for decidedly sub-par performances at that)? These administrations have added additional trillions to our great-grandchildren's debt -- and are continuing to do so -- with unaccounted payments for unnecessary wars in Iraq and Afghanistan that have made us less safe, while enriching the likes of Halliburton and Blackwater executives.

So let me get this straight, Congress and presidents are willing to add trillions to the national debt for the benefit of their largest campaign contributors, but when it comes to providing improved healthcare to the people who now rank 37th in the world, nearly 50 million of whom have no coverage at all, we can only make the improvements that won't add "one dime" to what we're now spending?

Have you been following the debate? Do you know how far we've fallen from the universal, single-payer ideal?

Do you know what the current plans consider a solution for those who are too poor to have health insurance? It's easy. Just pass a law requiring them to go out and buy health insurance. Then they'll have it -- and the insurance companies will have even more profits than they do now.

This is like providing housing for the homeless poor by passing a law requiring everyone to make mortgage payments to bankers -- a proposal as popular with Wall Street bankers as this "health care" proposal is with insurance executives, and just as unlikely to solve the problem.

It's a "win-win" -- at least for the elected officials who will continue to receive ever-more generous campaign contributions, and the insurance company executives who will continue to receive even bigger bonuses.

For us? It's a "lose-lose." We'll continue to pay more and get less than any other people on earth.

Oh, and they may not even have the votes to get that passed, since the Republican play book says defeating any healthcare reform is the best way to "crush" Obama and return the Republicans to power -- a goal that partisans of both parties all too often put ahead of the public welfare.

So that's where we are this morning.

I know there's a limit to the utility of anecdotal evidence in public policy debates. But I want to share the following with you anyway. It's a statement by a healthcare executive who thinks our present system is "broken" -- as indeed it is.

Original Blog Post: First, I am a registered Republican. Secondly, I am a healthcare executive and feel that I have an insider's view on our BROKEN healthcare system. It is my opinion that President Obama hit the nail on the head tonight [September 9, 2009, address to joint session of Congress on health care]. I was moved to tears by the reality and brilliancy of his speech. If you do nothing else, PLEASE take the time to educate yourself on the proposed reforms. Don't rely on the media or propaganda.

Comment from blog reader: I can't begin to argue with someone of your pedigree but I did not hear anything different tonight than what he has been saying. What is it that is so appealing to you?

Blogger's response to comment:

1. We have no option but to do SOMETHING.

2. Health insurance companies must be called to judgment. (Pre-existing conditions, cancellation without cause, arbitrary denials.)

3. There is huge waste in practicing defensive medicine, and pilot projects to reform this are a great start.

4. Accountability of providers by reporting outcomes is long overdue.

5. Options to provide catastrophic coverage to prevent bankruptcy are a necessity.

6. Get people out of the ERs for accessing primary care.

7. The lies and propaganda must stop. There is no proposal for a death panel, but merely a proposal to pay physicians for the time and effort it takes to counsel a patient on their options for end of life care. EVERYONE should have a plan. It is the right thing to do for one's family.

8. He is right. We CANNOT put this discussion and reform off any longer. We must act now for our own children and for the character of our country. I also believe we can do great things. . . . Unfortunately, I think most people get hung up in the politics (including the politicians) and so no significant change can occur.
The blog entry comes from the wife of a friend of mine, so I can vouch for her credentials as a healthcare executive -- and am willing to honor her desire for anonymity on my blog.

The point is, simply, that there are a goodly number of folks who do understand our present system, work within it, consider themselves conservatives, and yet when it comes to candid descriptions of the reality they know so well and the solutions we so desperately need, are if anything even more progressive than those hated "liberals."

After losing the presidential election in 1952, Adlai Stevenson said, "it hurts too much to laugh, but I'm too old to cry."

Those are our only options.

What can you say when it turns out "We're number 37" in the world in terms of the health care provided our people, we leave nearly 50 million with no insurance coverage at all, and we still end up paying more for the inadequate care we get as other countries?

You can make a song out of it:



Of course, to keep this blog entry balanced, under the spirit of the repealed Fairness Doctrine, I herewith present MoveOn.org's case for the abused health insurance executives:


____________

* Why do I put this blog ID at the top of the entry, when you know full well what blog you're reading? Because there are a number of Internet sites that, for whatever reason, simply take the blog entries of others and reproduce them as their own without crediting the source. I don't mind the flattering attention, but would appreciate acknowledgment as the source, even if I have to embed it myself. -- Nicholas Johnson

# # #

Monday, July 20, 2009

Health Costs, Rationing and Hypocrisy

July 20, 2009, 9:00 a.m.

Two Thoughts on Medical Bills
(brought to you by FromDC2Iowa.blogspot.com*)

There are a couple aspects of "the cost of health care" I'm going to try to put briefly this morning.

1. I believe that those public officials, and the campaign contributors who fund them, who so willingly handed over trillions of taxpayer dollars to some of America's wealthiest bankers this past year are now morally precluded from using "cost" as a reason for continuing to deny health care to Americans.

Am I concerned about sickness costs accelerating at a rate four times wages? Of course. It's not a trivial concern. But there are responses other than voting "No" on any and all proposed solutions.

(a) They talk of the added costs "over ten years." But a trillion dollars over 10 years is $100 billion a year. They gave that much to individual companies! To be able to provide health care to every American for the same amount puts both their prior generosity, and their current miserliness, in a clear, stark perspective.

(b) Where did this idea come from anyway that we can only have the quality of health care other countries provide their people if we can do it for no additional money? Of course it's going to cost money! We don't apply that standard to the defense budget. We don't apply it to earmarks and other corporate tax breaks, subsidies and giveaways. Why does it suddenly become our Polaris of navigation when it comes to keeping America healthy?

(2) "Rationing" health care. One of the arguments of the special-interest advocates, and their purchased public officials, in opposing universal, single-payer and public option plans is the bugaboo of "rationing."

(a) We already have "rationing." The rationing decisions are made by the executives of for-profit companies that make more profit, and pay those executives larger bonuses, by refusing to provide any insurance, or care for some, and denying the claims of others (all the while raising premiums). There are procedures, and drug treatments, they simply refuse to pay for. They try to suggest that there is no rationing in the present system, but that it would be imposed by "government bureaucrats" in the proposed reforms.

Give me a choice between a greed-driven rationing and even an incompetent (but at least not self-interested driven) rationing, and I'll choose the latter every time.

(b) We cannot provide every conceivable medical procedure known to everyone who might like to have it, regardless of cost. We can't, won't and don't pay for that approach whether with the insurance premiums paid to for-profit providers or with the taxes that support a public system.

There needs to be some metric, some way of thinking about, the benefit-cost returns in any health care system, private or public. It is not only economically essential, it is rational and reasonable, for a public system to focus on providing "the greatest good to the greatest number" by insisting that no one go without the relatively low cost procedures and medicines that can provide them more "quality years" of life -- even though the result may be that the very most expensive treatments have to be curtailed as a public expense (while retaining the option of a patient paying for them with cash, or an additional private insurance plan). The point is, that's what we do now. The very wealthiest get care the rest of us do not; we can't afford it, and our insurance policies won't cover it.

The advantage of a public option is that we would save the system money by getting the uninsured out of the emergency room and into a doctor's office (at a fraction of the cost). By providing medical care to all at the onset of disease, or immediately after an injury, by offering relatively cheap routine checkups, we'd not only improve Americans' health we'd also save the far greater future costs of treating more serious conditions.

Would this mean that some of us, some of the time, would not get public coverage of some treatment we might now get with our private for-profit insurance? Probably. But the opposite might also be true; there would undoubtedly be some treatments a non-profit system would conclude are cost-effective than a for-profit system refuses to provide. Regardless, we would have the benefit of a nationwide level of health -- of infant mortality rates, and life expectancy -- that would bring us closer to the standards of the rest of the industrialized world, with all the economic, humane and moral consequences of such a system.

This morning's blog entry was inspired by the following thoughtful, analytical, balanced article in yesterday's New York Times Magazine: Peter Singer, "Why We Must Ration Health Care/'Public Health Insurance Should Pay Up To $__________ For a Treatment That Would Extend a Patient's Life for One Year,'" New York Times, July 19, 2009, p. MM38.

If you're at all interested in this subject you need to read it.
_____________

* Why do I put this blog ID at the top of the entry, when you know full well what blog you're reading? Because there are a number of Internet sites that, for whatever reason, simply take the blog entries of others and reproduce them as their own without crediting the source. I don't mind the flattering attention, but would appreciate acknowledgment as the source, even if I have to embed it myself. -- Nicholas Johnson

# # #

Monday, July 13, 2009

Politics & Health Care: Both Rotten to the Core

July 13, 2009, 8:00 a.m.

Shameful Performance Should be Required Reading
(brought to you by FromDC2Iowa.blogspot.com*)

I'm angry. Really angry. Why do we take this? Why aren't Americans marching on Washington by the millions?

What the sickness industry and our puppet politicians have been demonstrating about the current operation of politics and "health care" in America is shameful. When it's all over, and President Obama proclaims the outcome "a good start," we will all continue to pay more and more, while getting less and less, year after year. The campaign contributions will increase, as will the compensation packages for the sickness industry's CEOs and the proportion of our premiums going to "administration" (already roughly 10 times those for Medicare/Medicaid, or what others countries pay).

Hopefully, after it's over, this shameful chapter of American politics and corporate control will be written up and made required reading for every school child and college student. What a lesson in the "decline and fall of the American empire" (to borrow from Gibbon's title); the control of our mass media; the revolving door phenomenon; the role of lobbyists; the power and use of deliberately misleading industry "talking points" by "their" elected officials and media outlets; the impact of campaign contributions on public policy; the price we pay for our failure to have public funding of campaigns; the willingness of Wall Street, corporate executives and elected officials to knowingly harm the health of the American people (as with the environment, or any other public good) in their drive to increase profits and their own personal power and wealth.

The potential list of references for these assertions of mine is endless, so I'll just provide three or four.

The Washington Post has named names and provided the details on the industry's power, and the former politicians' willingness, to come together in an overwhelming army of well-financed former insiders to swarm over Washington's elected and appointed officials. Dan Eggen and Kimberly Kindy, "Familiar Players in Health Bill Lobbying; Firms Are Enlisting Ex-Lawmakers, Aides," Washington Post, July 6, 2009.

Of course, this story was published after, and possibly as an effort to regain some of the paper's prior reputation before, the publisher was shamed.

How shamed? For the role of the mainstream media in the sickness industry's efforts see, Nicholas Johnson, "Rare Washington Post Apology Misses Mark," July 5, 2009. In case you missed the story, the Post's publisher was caught selling access to her reporters and editors, along with the Obama officials and legislators to whom she has the power to issue command performances, for small, off-the-record dinners at her home. The price tag: $25,000 per sickness industry lobbyist per dinner, or $250,000 for sickness industry lobbyists who feel they'd need a series of such opportunities to guarantee defeat of the "public option." So much for the days and heroes of Watergate fame.

The Nation has reported the formula for calculating how large a campaign contribution it takes to get a Democrat to oppose a "public option" in the bill (notwithstanding the fact that 76% of their constituents want it). Sebastian Jones, "Noted: Health and Wealth," The Nation, July 13, 2009 ("[T]he White House . . . starts at a significant disadvantage, perhaps as large as $1.38 billion. According to the Center for Responsive Politics . . . that's the sum that five industries -- pharmaceuticals/health products, insurance, health services/HMOs, hospitals/nursing homes and health professionals -- spent lobbying lawmakers . . .. Beyond lobbying, hundreds of millions have been spent . . . in campaign contributions . . .. So what does all this money buy? According to Nate Silver . . . the low sum of $60,000 in campaign contributions over the past six years would cut in half the odds of a centrist Democrat supporting [a "public option" in] the plan").

Last week I wrote in the Des Moines Register: "The for-profit marketplace does some things well. Health care's not one of them. We pay more while covering fewer and getting less, with more rapidly increasing costs, than any country on Earth. Insurance companies create the ever-increasing profits Wall Street demands by ever-increasing premiums, denying coverage to some and the legitimate claims of others." See, Nicholas Johnson, "Why GOP Fears Meaningful Health Care," July 8, 2009.

A confession: The statement about Wall Street's involvement, increasing premiums and denial of coverage and claims, was intuition. It just seemed to me when I wrote that it was probably what is going on.

Two days later I had the reassurance of affirmation of my intuition from someone who knows, from the inside, and from the top of the inside, how the sickness industry functions. See, e.g., Trish Nelson, "Insurance Insider Reveals Industry Tactics Intended to Kill Health Care Reform," BlogForIowa, July 12, 2009.

His name is Wendell Potter, a former senior vice president of communications for Cigna, the fourth largest health insurance company in the country -- the single live guest on "Bill Moyers Journal," PBS, July 10, 2009. Here is the the main Moyers' Web site, and the page for the show with Potter (both with lots of additional, related, material and links to more).

It's an absolutely appalling tale he has to tell about Wall Street's pressure on the companies, the companies' refusal to cover some and denying the claims of others, the lobbying efforts, the deliberate misrepresentation of the issues, and the full bore attempt to discredit and marginalize Michael Moore's documentary, "Sicko" -- about which Potter acknowledged, "I thought that he [Moore] hit the nail on the head with his movie." For some reason, this portion of the Moyers' interview was deleted from the PBS and Moyers' sites; it can, however, be found here.



You owe it to yourself to take a look at the portion of the interview that PBS/Moyers does make available, and to check out the other information and links from their sites.

This is a tragic, despicable, shameful story in the history of American capitalism and politics that we all need to understand.
_____________

* Why do I put this blog ID at the top of the entry, when you know full well what blog you're reading? Because there are a number of Internet sites that, for whatever reason, simply take the blog entries of others and reproduce them as their own without crediting the source. I don't mind the flattering attention, but would appreciate acknowledgment as the source, even if I have to embed it myself. -- Nicholas Johnson

# # #