Showing posts with label Senator Tom Harkin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Senator Tom Harkin. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

A Car in Every Garage

December 16, 2008, 7:30 a.m.

Harkin Didn't Write Again Today
(Brought to you by FromDC2Iowa.blogspot.com)

Iowa's Senator Tom Harkin is drawing on the politics of fellow Iowan Herbert Hoover, who once promised "a chicken in every pot, a car in every garage" -- but you have to get your own chicken.

If all a CEO wants to do is keep her company from going bankrupt laying off workers makes economic sense -- especially if the top priority is hanging on to her multi-million-dollar salary and benefits package. And if she's a friend of yours, and you are a government official with the discretionary ability to dispense trillions of dollars, giving her a few billion also makes sense.

But if what you're trying to do is turn around the economy, it doesn't make a lot of sense to give money to the CEOs who are trying to sell stuff rather than the consumers who would like to buy stuff, have the power to drive 70% of our economy, and are out of work because of some CEO's decision.

As I wrote here recently: "Only when we put more money in the hands of consumers (or permit them to keep more of what they have) will there be any true rescue of the auto -- or any other American -- industry. This is one of those times when even if your only goal is to further enrich the wealthy, the only way to do it is to let the money trickle up, not down." Nicholas Johnson, "Quick Fix for the Economy," December 12, 2008.

It was nearly a month ago that I wrote "Auto Bailout: An Open Letter to Congress," November 19, 2008, addressed to the two Iowa senators and our local congressman. Since I don't presume this blog is the first thing they read every morning I also sent the letter to them the old fashioned way, through the postal service.

Dave Letterman had a running joke on his CBS "Late Night" show about his desire to appear on Oprah's TV show. He'd call his office, ask if Oprah had called that day, and then enter in his journal, "Oprah didn't call again today."

Well, "Senator Harkin didn't answer again today." It's a sad commentary about the disconnect between we the constituents and those who are supposed to be our "elected representatives." Read the "open letter," linked above. It seems to me the questions were pretty straight forward and involved matters of great consequence (the auto bailout) not only for Iowans, but for Americans generally.

(It's reminiscent of a conversation with a friend of mine a while back. She asked what I'd been doing and I replied that I was just staying at home, near the phone, thinking she might call. To which she replied, "How's that been working for you?" It was working kind of like the country-western line, "Since my phone still ain't ringing I assume it still ain't you," from Randy Travis' "Is It Still Over?" Well, checking my mailbox at the post office every day for replies from Washington hasn't been working for me any better than sitting by the phone.)

However, I at least want to give Harkin credit for an idea that is responsive to my endow-the-consumers-not-the-CEOs approach -- as well as a family member's suggestion that every American family be given a car. (We priced that one out and realized the cost was a few orders of magnitude beyond even the generosity of this Administration and Congress.)

Here's the story, as presented by Des Moines TV station KCCI:

Sen. Tom Harkin . . . introduced a bill earlier this week that in turn would take older, less-fuel-efficient cars off the road, while also giving buyers a big bonus.

The Sell Fuel Efficient Cars Act would provide a rebate of $10,000 to buyers who trade in a car more than 10 years old for a new American car. . . .

The rebate would be limited to families with an adjusted gross income below $40,000 a year or individuals making less than $25,000.

To get the rebate, you would be required to turn in a car more than 10 years old that is still drivable.

The rebate would only apply to purchases of fuel-efficient GM, Ford or Chrysler vehicles that are assembled in the United States. The car would have to have an average fuel economy of 25 miles per gallon.

Officials said close to 15 percent of automobiles that are manufactured by the Big Three automakers would qualify for the rebate.

There would be a one-car limit per family or individual and the program would end in 2009.
"Harkin Proposes $10K Auto Purchase Rebate," KCCI-TV8, December 12, 2008.

Commentary:

"A snowball's chance . . .." Snow balls have a great chance of survival in Iowa these days, indeed entire snowmen. The hell of Washington is, however, another matter. But this blog has always been more attracted to what's right, what's rational, than to what's expedient.

Win-win. Look at what all this proposal accomplishes. (1) It gets money to the Big Three auto companies, but by running it through the hands of consumers and the marketplace rather than handing it over to CEOs. (2) The money is not just free cash that can be used for anything (like the banks' bailout that was supposed to be used for loans, but instead was hoarded and used to buy up other banks); it is limited to the purchase of automobiles. (3) The retention of jobs (by suppliers and dealers as well as auto manufacturers) is dependent upon the sale (and therefore manufacture) of automobiles. No "solution" that does not involve the manufacture and sale of automobiles is a solution worthy of the name. (4) It puts money in the hands of those who need it most, individuals earning less than $25,000 or families earning less than $40,000 -- significantly more humane, and economically efficient, than further enriching those in the top 1/10th of 1% of wage earners. (5) It gets old and often unsafe cars off the road (those over 10 years old; although, disclosure: my vehicle turned 30 years old this year). (6) Because older cars tend to be less fuel efficient, and possibly more polluting, it helps reduce our dependence on foreign oil and harm from greenhouse gases. (7) It encourages Detroit to manufacture more fuel efficient vehicles.

Those are some of the positives. Now for some of the problems I see with this idea.

(1) This bill will probably never pass, so its primary value is just to get us thinking about how we ought to be going about our economic recovery -- no small contribution, but not an answer.

(2) Those who most need this kind of help may not be in an economic position to accept it. If we're talking about new cars that sell for something between $15,000 and $35,000, and folks who are earning between $25,000 and $40,000, and driving a 10-year-old car, those are the very people who are either out of work or about to be, people whose home may be in foreclosure, or whose credit cards are maxed out. They probably have neither the $5000 to $25,000 in cash, nor the ability to get that kind of credit, to enable them to buy a car -- even with the $10,000 rebate. Of course, if we're talking new cars selling for $12,000-$14,000 that's another matter.

(3) I was frankly surprised to read that only 15% of the cars made in Detroit can get 25 mpg -- and even that number is far more likely to be overstated than understated ("your mileage may vary"). Shouldn't the plan at least call for 35 mpg (my wife drives a 10-year-old Mazda four-door that gets 38 mpg highway)? Maybe electric; maybe hybred; maybe smaller vehicles. (India's new 50 mpg, $2500 Tata Nano might not be what Americans are looking for, but it does offer something to stimulate one's imagination as to what American manufacturers could design, build and sell.)

So thanks, Senator, for hopefully stimulating some more imaginative thinking in Washington and Detroit -- but I'd still kind of like an answer to my letter.

# # #

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Auto Bailout: An Open Letter to Congress

November 19, 2008, 10:15 a.m.

An Onion That Will Make You Laugh as Well as Cry
Followed by an Open Letter To My Senators and Congressman
Brought to You by http://FromDC2Iowa.blogspot.com




[Credit: The Onion; Source: In The Know: Should The Government Stop Dumping Money Into A Giant Hole?]

Open Letter to My Senators and Congressman
Regarding the Big Three Auto Bailout

[Note: This letter has been sent by mail as well as published here. Such responses as I may receive from these three officials -- or the fact that I get no response from one or more -- will be reported here.]

Dear Senators Grassley, Harkin and Congressman Loebsack:

Thank you for your willingness to address one of the toughest sets of economic challenges any Congress has ever confronted, and to search for governmental responses that will produce more good than harm.

I do not believe the proposed auto bailout is such a response.

Press reports indicate you intend to support it anyway. See, e.g., Thomas Beaumont, "Grassley tells auto execs: Cut your pay to $1," Des Moines Register, November 17, 2008.

So I have some questions for you that I hope you will be good enough to answer -- as well as providing me with sources on the Internet where I can find the reports and data you have relied on in coming to your position.

1. Overview. All data I know of suggests that major indicators -- manufacturing output, consumer confidence and purchasing, unemployment, mortgage foreclosures -- are all going to continue to get worse, and probably at an accelerating rate, for the foreseeable future. Indeed, I know of no scenarios indicating how, when or why things will turn around.

Questions: Under these circumstances, don't you think it would make more sense for Congress in general, and you in particular, to be examining, and proposing solutions for, the entire economy rather than the industry-by-industry approach currently in vogue? If you, or others, have in fact already done this please refer me to sources on the Internet I could also examine.

2. Costs. Keynesian economics, and many of today's economists, urge the benefits of government spending in times of economic recession. But benefits are usually accompanied with costs, which is why we have benefit-cost analysis. It's one thing to ramp up government spending when national debt is low and budgets are nearly in balance. But we currently have $55 trillion in unfunded future obligations, a $12 trillion debt, and an annual budget deficit currently adding $1 trillion a year (or more) to that national debt.

Questions: Accepting that there may be benefits from government bailouts, what are the short and long term costs -- perhaps in runaway inflation, deflation, third-world-style national bankruptcy, or other comparable economic calamities, and where on the Internet might I find the independent reports and analyses that you and others have access to regarding these risks? My three great grandchildren -- whom you and I are asking to pay the debts we've run up -- have asked me to find out from you.

3. Consumers. We currently have 10 million unemployed -- with monthly increases, and even increases in the rate of increase. Two-thirds of our economy is driven by consumer spending. I have written of my problems with the $700 billion bailout you supported (problems which even Secretary Paulson now acknowledges) as well as the auto industry bailout (and the $25 billion you earlier provided the Big Three). We have yet to see any economic turnaround from those unprecedented massive expenditures.

Questions: Why do you believe that "trickle down" -- giving money to corporate CEOs, with or without conditions, to operate their companies -- is more effective than "trickle up" -- a jobs program and prevention of mortgage foreclosures, putting money in the hands of consumers?

4. Infrastructure. The New York Times reports that the Chinese "government said [its $586 billion] stimulus would cover . . . low-income housing, electricity, water, rural infrastructure . . . environmental protection and technological innovation — [to] incite consumer spending and bolster the economy." David Barboza, “China Unveils Sweeping Plan for Economy,” New York Times, November 9, 2008. Including roads, bridges, schools, hospitals, flood prevention, disaster recovery -- our own list of priority public projects is seemingly endless.

Questions: Why, to the limited extent that you and your fellow members of Congress have concerned yourselves with the needs of individual American people (as distinguished from our corporations), have you focused on unemployment insurance and food stamps rather than a massive jobs program that would not only put money into the hands of the only people who can improve the economy, but would buy us a rebuilt America as well?

5. Problem. The multi-million-dollar-a-year auto executives who profess to be concerned about the "three million unemployed" if you don't bail them out are very wide of the mark. In an economic depression with no end in sight, 10 million unemployed with more every passing day, automobile sales are down and will undoubtedly decline further. And many to most of such automobiles as will be sold will not be sold by the Big Three anyway.

This depression has produced pain for those who work in automobile manufacturing, dealerships and suppliers -- already 500,000 lost jobs in Michigan alone -- as well as in every other major sector of our economy, including retail. It is going to produce more pain in the months and years to come. Whether you provide the $25 billion bailout, or not; or the companies go through Chapter 11, or not, consumers are not going to buy more cars and layoffs will continue.

As we've recently seen with CitiBank, you gave them $25 billion and what did they do -- they laid off nearly 100,000 workers. Whatever else you may call it, clearly your approach to the auto industry is highly unlikely to end up being a jobs program.

GM has gone through $185 billion in cash over the last few years; its stock has declined 90%. A full year ago it reported losing $39 billion in one quarter ("the second largest quarterly loss in U.S. history. . . . GM is hemorrhaging money . . . and the outlook for 2008 and beyond is bleak." Associated Press, "GM posts huge $39 billion net loss," MSNBC, November 7, 2007.) Its problem is not a temporary "cash flow" problem that will be resolved by next January or February; and it cannot be solved with a temporary loan that will be repaid by January or February.

Although even Secretary Paulson now agrees that you were wrong to vote for the plan he put before you, I am giving you the benefit of the doubt: I assume you are applying the wisdom of "fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me," and that you have had access to, studied, and been persuaded by a detailed business plan for the auto industry bailout you apparently support.

Questions: Where on the Internet can I find the business plan that you are presumably relying upon that documents, precisely, how this $25 billion is to be used, and how, why and when it will solve these three companies' problems, revive the industry, and why it will eliminate any need for them to regularly return to you for more taxpayer money?

Thank you for your assistance and for working on our behalf.

Respectfully,


Nicholas Johnson
Constituent and Taxpayer

# # #